Is Being Pregnant Riskier than Using the Pill?

by Michel Accad, MD

Yes hormonal contraception has risks, but pregnancy is even more risky!”

No doubt, readers of the CANFP NEWS are familiar with this argument or a version of it. What may be less familiar is the “evidence” that pill pushers use to advance that claim.

While preparing a CANFP talk on the physical harms of contraception, I came across the following table that claims to compare the risks of childbirth-related deaths to the risks of death from methods of “fertility control” employed by women, broken down by age group. Not surprisingly, the table indicates that to use oral contraception is generally much safer than to be pregnant. I found the table in the package insert of one of the pills but, as far as I can tell, the table seems to be included in the package insert of every single oral contraceptive. That surprised me, since each package insert is prepared independently by the manufacturer before being sanctioned by the FDA. But that also told me that, in all likelihood, the table represents the strongest possible evidence pill advocates can muster to support the claim that pregnancy is more risky than contraception.

So I examined the table and the paper to find out how strong the evidence really was, and the first thing that I noticed was that the reference from which the table was adapted was published in 1982. Not exactly the most current information!  

The second thing I noticed was that the name of the journal in which the paper was published, Family Planning Perspectives, didn’t sound like a major medical publication that would have the highest standard of scholarship. In fact, the name seemed to betray a certain point of view on the question…Well, you may have guessed it already, but Family Planning Perspectives was in fact a journal published by no other than the Guttmacher Institute, the “research” arm of Planned Parenthood! How is that for an unbiased perspective?!

More importantly, the idea that one could accurately compare mortality rates from pregnancy to those of contraception struck me as likely to be fraught with great methodological difficulty. To begin with, any paper that purports to make a meaningful mortality comparison between different groups must ensure that the groups are reasonably similar in all aspects, except in regards to the variable of interest (e.g., in this case, the method of fertility control). Did this paper rise to the challenge?

As you might expect, the article didn’t even attempt to address this difficulty. The author, a physician of the Center for Disease Control (CDC), simply plucked mortality rate estimates from a handful of studies, each of which looked at a given group, and each of which had its own follow-up period, its own particularities, and its own methodological limitations. The data thus extracted could not possibly be used to make any meaningful comparisons between the groups.

The paper made no attempt to control for various factors that might affect the mortality rates. In fact, one could argue that the mere attempt to compare “childbirth related death rates to “method related” death rates is scientifically suspect, if not ludicrous, since using or not using a method of fertility control is a choice, and human choices are influenced by an unfathomable number of personal and socio-economic factors. Any of these factors could have an independent influence on mortality rates, and there is really no good way to attribute the difference in mortality to the use or method of fertility control.

And if we must compare “method-related” death rates to “birth-related” death rates, one would also think that the time frame for follow-up would be important. Shouldn’t long term survival be the variable of interest as opposed to annual mortality? For example, we know that using hormonal contraceptives and delaying childbirth are associated with increased breast cancer risks. Did the article take this into account?

As it turns out, in those studies chosen to estimate oral contraceptive-related deaths, only deaths from blood clots, strokes and heart attacks were counted against the pill. Yet we know that the use of the pill can alter a woman’s behavior and circumstances in a multiplicity of ways, some of which could very reasonably be a factor in lethal outcomes. In addition to increased cancer risks, some studies have shown increased suicide rates among current or former pill users. Yet none of these outcomes were counted against the pill here.

One of the most egregious way in which the article skewed the data in favor of oral contraceptives can be appreciated in the following quote from the paper:

“Estimates of maternal mortality published here are those deaths related to ectopic pregnancy and childbirth, and are based on US vital statistics from 1972 through 1978, inflated by 33 percent to account for well documented under-reporting.” (italics mine)

While it may be the case that US vital statistics under-report childbirth deaths (public health statistics of this sort are notoriously unreliable), it is a scientific sleight-of-hand to selectively increase those numbers, while keeping mortality rates from oral contraceptives to an obviously misleading bare minimum.

And I am barely scratching the surface here. I will spare the readers how mortality rates for women using “periodic abstinence” were determined…

In conclusion, the claim that pregnancy risks are greater than contraceptive risks has no basis in sound scientific evidence. But the evidence that Planned Parenthood and the Guttmacher Institute are playing a game of pure deception, is there for all to see.

Dr.-Accad-presenting2014
Table-YAZ-Package-Insert1-150x150

About The Author

Michel Accad, MD
Dr. Michel Accad, Professional Membver of CANFP, practices internal medicine and cardiology in San Francisco, and holds clinical appointments at UC San Francisco and at the San Francisco Heart and Vascular Institute.
Dr.-Accad-presenting2014
Table-YAZ-Package-Insert1-150x150

Comments

Commenting on articles is a member-only feature. Please sign up for one of our memberships to leave a comment.
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Continue Reading Similar Articles

CANFP NEWS Summer 2026

PMOS: New Name for a Familiar Condition

by Jean Golden-Tevald, DO, CFMC, FCP, FMCP-M

For years, NFP and fertility awareness educators, fertility care practitioners, and healthcare professionals have helped women understand the complexities of

CANFP NEWS Spring 2026

Infertility, Pregnancy Loss, and Infection: New Insights

by Mary Davenport, MD, MS

Many of us are familiar with a typical investigation for the causes of infertility and miscarriage: hormones, polycystic ovarian syndrome,

CANFP NEWS Winter 2026

Contraception Use, Effectiveness and Adverse Effects

by Robert Chasuk, MD

The topic of contraception methods in use today is quite broad, so this short article will be a high-altitude overview

CANFP NEWS Fall 2025

The Beauty and Wisdom of RRM

by Lynn Keenan, MD

On September 16, 2025, I was honored to participate in the congressional briefing arranged by the International Institute of Restorative

CANFP NEWS Spring 2025

Armchair Chat: Prenatal Screening Advice from a Catholic OB/GYN

by Theresa Stigen, MD, ObGyn

Prenatal screening testing has changed a lot since I began my OB/GYN residency in 2004. Initially, we only ordered a

CANFP NEWS Winter 2025

D4, Called to Service

by Deacon Julian Delgado, MD

I was privileged to be born and raised in a very faithful Catholic family. My folks not only taught us

Fall 2024

Navigating Menopause

by Gretchen Marsh, D.O.

Menopause is a natural process that marks the end of a woman’s reproductive years when menstruation permanently stops. It is

Summer 2024

The Three “C”s of Marriage

by George Delgado, M.D.

Wise people have said, “As the family goes so society goes”. For years, we have bemoaned the divorce rate in

Spring 2024

IVF: Not a Panacea but a Pandora’s Box

by Lauren Rubal, MD, FACOG

The news cycle has finally focused on an area of medicine that typically goes under the radar: in vitro fertilization

Winter 2024

The Fractured Self

by Victoria Schneider M.D

The dissection of gender away from biological sex causes a fracture in one’s self—one’s sense of who one is, how

Fall 2023

Sleep: Time to Heal

by Lynn Keenan, MD

Have you ever wondered why we spend so much time sleeping? I remember my first trip to Ireland, standing outside

Summer 2023

NFP: Scientific, Healthy, and Effective

by Mary Davenport, MD, MS

Natural Family Planning (NFP) is a couple’s observation and acceptance of their phases of fertility for the purposes of achieving

Create An Account

This is not a membership, this is an account for our CANFP website. If you decide you would like to sign up for one of our memberships later, you can do so with or without this account.

First Name *
Last Name *
E-mail *
Username *
Password *
Confirm Password *
Edit Profile
Information
Subscriptions & Payment Method
Payment History
Order History
Downloads
Shipping and Billing
Donations
Settings
Login Information
Notification Settings
Notification Subscriptions
Profile

CANFP conducts varied outreach programs to the community at large, in addition to serving our members (NFP users, teachers, and advocates).

CANFP provides education programs tailored to the audience, not only on Natural Family Planning, but on the wide variety of topics related to it.

Programs can be continuing education for NFP Professionals, introductory information for a lay audience of youth or adults new to the topic, or specifically tailored to the interests of a professional audience, such as educators, physicians, or clergy. Content is faith based or secular, whichever is suitable for situation.

CANFP offers a variety of resources for those just discovering Natural Family Planning, as well as to meet the varied needs of our CANFP Members. Most resources are available to any visitors to our site. Some resources do ask you to register as a site user in order to access them, others are available only to CANFP Members.

CANFP statewide conferences, regional events offered in collaboration with local partners, events featuring CANFP speakers, or exhbit, as well as other events throughout the state of interest to our NFP community.  Come meet one of our experts at one of these events or book a speaker for your own upcoming event.

CANFP depends on the gifts, talents, and generosity of our members and supporters. The success of our mission depends on the collaboration of our members. Please consider contributing your time treasure and talent through CANFP to share the good news of NFP with the world! Both volunteer and contracted positions available.

Stay informed by joining our email list

* indicates required
Which role(s) best describes you?