Examining the Difference Between NFP and Contraception

by Professor Tom Cavanaugh
Spring 2023

Let’s compare natural family planning (NFP) with contraception. This may help us to remember what is at stake in embracing NFP while rejecting contraceptives. To assess a tool, we ask: what is it for? One significant defect of contraception is that it purposefully renders sexual intercourse baby-free. Yet, a baby is one prominent goal of intercourse – another is union of the couple. Unlike contraception, NFP does not render sex sterile. Rather, NFP respects the baby- and union-oriented character of intimacy.

Say someone acknowledges that contraception morally differs from NFP. How big a difference are we talking about? Thomas Aquinas (a philosopher, theologian, wise moral thinker, and saint whom the Catholic Church repeatedly recommends as a guide) speaks of contraception as preventing “the generation of human nature.” In other words, contraception prevents a baby. He says that such acts take a “place next to” acts that destroy “an already existing human nature.” Or, in other words, acts that, for example, destroy a baby. So, how is contraception next to such an act? Consider how a common contraceptive that prevents a baby can also cause miscarriage.

While usage varies, about one-eighth (12.5%) of women in the U.S. who use contraception rely on hormonal intra-uterine devices (IUDs). As its name suggests, the IUD is placed within the woman’s uterus. Hormonal IUDs are coated with a progestin (a synthetic progestogen that mimics the natural hormone progesterone). The naturally synthesized hormone progesterone gets its name from ‘pro’ meaning “to further or promote,” gestare meaning “to carry, bear, or carry in the womb,” and ‘one’ which as used here means a “chemical bond.” Thus, progesterone – as its name suggests – is a chemical molecule that helps a woman become and remain pregnant.

So, why use a progestin to prevent a baby? There are a couple of reasons. First, as found in a hormonal IUD, progestin inhibits ovulation, or egg-release: no egg, no sperm meeting egg (fertilization). That is, no baby. In effect, progestin makes the woman’s brain and body think that the sperm and egg have already met, that she is with baby. In response, the woman’s body reduces ovulation. It does not, however, entirely eliminate ovulation

This brings us to the second reason to use progestin to prevent a baby. Once inside the woman, sperm swim to her egg through cervical mucus. The best mucus for sperm to swim to the ovum is wet and abundant.
Progestin dries out the cervical mucus, making it thick. Progestin also decreases the amount of cervical mucus. Both of these effects of progestin make it more difficult for sperm to swim to the egg, reducing the likelihood of sperm meeting egg.

The above two mechanisms are contraceptive in nature. That is, they lower the chance of the sperm meeting the ovum by reducing both ovulation and sperm-mobility. Thus, progestin as found in an IUD prevents the baby-making act from baby-making. It does not, however, entirely eliminate sperm meeting egg (baby-making or fertilization). This brings us to a third reason people have for using a hormonal IUD.

The third mechanism is not contraceptive in nature. Rather, it causes miscarriage. For this reason the hormonal IUD is called an ‘abortifacient’. ‘Abortifacient’ comes from the Latin ‘ab’ meaning “amiss,” ‘oriri’ meaning “born,” and ‘facere’ meaning “to make.” As its name suggests, an abortifacient causes a mis-birth or a miscarriage.

How does a hormonal IUD occasionally cause a miscarriage? Progestin thins the lining of the uterus (the endometrium), thereby making it less hospitable to a fertilized ovum, embryo, a.k.a., baby. As noted above, the chance of fertilization is reduced but not eliminated in a woman using a hormonal IUD. Were fertilization to occur, the embryo would have difficulty implanting in the uterus due to the thinned endometrium. This effect of progestin as found in a hormonal IUD is called ‘desynchronization.’ As its name suggests, desynchronization makes the embryo and the uterus out of step with one another. This means that when the embryo is ready to implant in the uterus, the uterus is not ready to receive the embryo. Thus, the baby is miscarried. The hormonal IUD causes such a miscarriage. In this respect, it is an abortifacient; its use results in the loss of the baby.

Hormonal IUDs can last from three to eight years. While it is difficult to determine the frequency of miscarriage with precision and accuracy, a typical user of a hormonal IUD would likely experience miscarriage over a three-year period. Indeed, it might occur annually; again, it is difficult to determine. Regardless of frequency, the hormonal IUD occasionally causes the death of the embryo, a human being. One willing to use it knowing that it has this effect is willing to destroy a human being.

As noted above, Aquinas positions contraception as distinct from, yet next to, the destruction of a human being. In the instance of the widely used hormonal IUD, we see that the deliberate prevention of conception intimately relates to, indeed, is effected by the exact same synthetic molecular chemical that prevents the embryo from implanting, resulting in its death. Accordingly, we see, as Aquinas notes, that being willing to prevent the conception of a human being (contraception) is next to being willing to destroy an already existing human being. For this and countless further allied reasons, we do well to shun contraceptives while embracing wholesome NFP. For contracepted sexual intercourse drastically differs from sexual intercourse open to life.

Human Development
IUD

About The Author

Professor Tom Cavanaugh
Professor Tom Cavanaugh teaches philosophy at the University of San Francisco. In 2018, Oxford University Press published his book entitled, Hippocrates’ Oath and Asclepius’ Snake: The Birth of the Medical Profession. For his work on the Hippocratic Oath, he received the 2019 Smith Award for Lifetime Achievement in Medical Ethics from University Faculty for Life. He continues to research and publish in medical ethics, the history of medical ethics, and the Catholic intellectual tradition.
Human Development
IUD

Comments

Commenting on articles is a member-only feature. Please sign up for one of our memberships to leave a comment.
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Continue Reading Similar Articles

Fall 2023

NFP Questions My Kids Asked (or Should Have)

by Gary Schuberg

Over the 40 years of our marriage, NFP has been a natural(!) part of family conversation, over meals and at

Summer 2023

We Share Your Joy!

by Therese Maes

This joyous time of preparation for your marriage may seem too full, too fast, too frenzied with “to-do” lists. But

Summer 2023

To the Lovers About to Make the Leap

by Gregory Polito, MD

Congratulations on your forthcoming launch into the sea of matrimony! There will be lots of troughs and crests in this

Winter 2023

One Sequoia After Another

by Fr. Blaise Berg, STD

“One sequoia after another!” texted my friend, Fr. Richard McDonald of Kansas (who attended CANFP’s HV50 conference in 2018). Fr.

Fall 2022

The Brave New World Post-Roe

by George Delgado, M.D., F.A.A.F.P.

The infamous Roe v. Wade and Doe v. Bolton Supreme Court decisions, that were relegated to the heap of jurisprudence

Summer 2022

Surfing as Prelude to NFP

by Gary Schuberg

Before you scoff at this notion, be mindful that one of the world’s finest Catholic apologists, Peter Kreeft, penned a

Summer 2022

Living NFP and the Formation of a Soccer Player

by Al Arévalo

Like many soccer players in their youth, I dreamt of playing professionally one day. To that end, playing soccer was

Summer 2022

Natural Family Planning: Foundation for Building a Culture of Life—Quotable Insights

by CANFP

“CANFP rejoices in the U.S. Supreme Court Dobbs decision which overturned the 1973 Roe v. Wade law legalizing abortion nation-wide.

Spring 2022

The Family as Domestic Church

by Timothy T. O’Donnell, STD, KGCHS

There is no doubt that the most important document issued by the Holy See in recent history on the family

How My Pastor Established a Successful Parish NFP Program

by Camille Iorns

As a Creighton Model Practitioner I was very blessed to have a supportive priest who spoke regularly about contraception and

I Just Wish Someone Had Told Me This Sooner

by Sheila St. John

Couples who come to learn Natural Family Planning are as diverse as their reasons for using it, but one sentiment

St. Joseph: Strong Man, Husband and Father

by Fr. Blaise Berg, STD

With this CANFP News dedicated to the Year of St. Joseph, it is appropriate to spend some time reflecting on

Create An Account

This is not a membership, this is an account for our CANFP website. If you decide you would like to sign up for one of our memberships later, you can do so with or without this account.

First Name *
Last Name *
E-mail *
Username *
Password *
Confirm Password *
Edit Profile
Information
Subscriptions
Payments
Order History
Downloads
Shipping and Billing
Donations
Settings
Login Information
Notification Settings
Notification Subscriptions
Profile

CANFP conducts varied outreach programs to the community at large, in addition to serving our members (NFP users, teachers, and advocates).

CANFP provides education programs tailored to the audience, not only on Natural Family Planning, but on the wide variety of topics related to it.

Programs can be continuing education for NFP Professionals, introductory information for a lay audience of youth or adults new to the topic, or specifically tailored to the interests of a professional audience, such as educators, physicians, or clergy. Content is faith based or secular, whichever is suitable for situation.

CANFP offers a variety of resources for those just discovering Natural Family Planning, as well as to meet the varied needs of our CANFP Members. Most resources are available to any visitors to our site. Some resources do ask you to register as a site user in order to access them, others are available only to CANFP Members.

CANFP statewide conferences, regional events offered in collaboration with local partners, events featuring CANFP speakers, or exhbit, as well as other events throughout the state of interest to our NFP community.  Come meet one of our experts at one of these events or book a speaker for your own upcoming event.

CANFP depends on the gifts, talents, and generosity of our members and supporters. The success of our mission depends on the collaboration of our members. Please consider contributing your time treasure and talent through CANFP to share the good news of NFP with the world! Both volunteer and contracted positions available.

Stay informed by joining our email list

* indicates required
Which role(s) best describes you?